Hi Lifehacker, I've just discovered that I cannot claim HECS-HELP repayments as a tax deduction. This makes no sense to me. If I pay my course fees up front I can claim them as a self-education expense, but if I repay them to the government I can't? What gives? Thanks, Educate Me
Ask Lifehacker is presented by Optus.
Find out how Optus can help you Live More Yes!
The Australian Taxation Office (ATO) is indeed quite clear on this point: you can't claim HECS-HELP fees as a self-education expense when you start paying them back.
Whether you can claim fees paid up-front actually depends on the kind of course you do. If it's a full-fee course, then you can claim those costs as a self-education expense if they relate to your work. However, if you take a Commonwealth supported place and pay your HECS-HELP up-front (which attracts a discount), you can't claim that as an education expense either. (As a full-time student, the chances are you won't be paying much tax in any case.)
The core logic appears to be this: since your course is being subsidised by taxpayers, it's not reasonable for you to also reduce your taxable income when you pay it back. It's not consistent — but that's true of many other tax rules as well. Such is life.
There are contentious government proposals to change how HECS-HELP fees are calculated, but those don't include any provision to change their tax-deductible status.
Got your own question you want to put to Lifehacker? Send it using our contact form.
Student picture from Shutterstock