Why I'm Sad That Google Is Killing Off Labs

Google has announced that it is "winding down" Labs, its system of introducing new features as experimental prototypes. While I don't imagine that means the end of innovation from Google, it does mark an unfortunate change in the way we get to experience those innovations.

Picture via Muppet Wiki

In a post on its official blog, Google explained that its decision to stop using Labs as a testing ground was so that it could focus on larger changes (an obvious if unmentioned example being the recent rollout of Google+):

We’ve decided to wind down Google Labs. While we’ve learned a huge amount by launching very early prototypes in Labs, we believe that greater focus is crucial if we’re to make the most of the extraordinary opportunities ahead.

The simpler interpretation of this: Google is having to marshal its resources to face increasing competitive pressures. The most obvious of these is Facebook, which despite its various privacy scandals remains the standout candidate for taking over from Google as the site most people begin and end their browsing experience with. It also represents the most visible competitor to Google for advertising dominance. (In the US, Bing also represents a threat in that area, but the anaemic subset of features Bing users get in Australia means that's less of an issue locally.)

The change doesn't mean that all Labs options are going to disappear overnight. Right now, labs settings are still available in Gmail, Maps, Chrome and other key Google products. But this announcement does mean that over time, the options offered there will either get rolled into the parent Google product or disappear. (Annoyingly, they might well just stop working without anything resembling an official statement.)

Labs has always been clearly presented as a set of options that could evaporate or change at any time, so it shouldn't come as a shock that Google has decided to stop using that approach. What it ultimately reflects — and what makes me a little sad — is that Google has totally shed its original image as an experimental workplace where creativity determined what might happen. Now it's a completely corporate approach: counting the dollars, measuring the ROI, and encouraging a group attitude and big projects rather than individual innovation.

In a way, it's surprising that this change took so long; Google hasn't been a small company since listing in 2004 (and that's being generous). And we already have a fair idea how Google will roll out its products in the future: by trying to keep a lid on major developments and then suddenly announcing something big, just like everybody else does. That won't always work: there will be leaks, just as there are when Apple or Microsoft or Sony try the same thing.

But we are going to lose some of that sense of being in early, of feeling like we're in on the process, not just getting something delivered when a large company decides it will make the most sense for profit. That process didn't always work perfectly, but it did give Google a clear point of distinction from its rivals that is now going to be lost.

That's my initial reaction to the Google Labs announcement. What's yours?

More wood behind fewer arrows [Official Google Blog]


Comments

    I love Gmail, but I love it SO MUCH more because of all the Labs I have enabled. I'd hate it if they disappeared. I hope they just get rolled into the settings.

    I think this also relates to the dwindling commitment to "20% time" at Google. Devs are simply required to focus their efforts more directly...

    There's an update at the end of the article:

    3:36pm: To clarify: we don't have any plans to change in-product experimentation channels like Gmail Labs or Maps Labs. We'll continue to experiment with new features in each of our products.

    I wasn't sad, but having read the article now I am. Thanks.

    Labs was the only time that the whole 20% time seemed to really have an impact. I have heard from people that 20% is not all its cracked up to be anyway, but the idea seemed nice.

    Interesting that this is happening after Larry Page has taken over from Eric Schmidt.

    This is sad.
    I totally agree, the "being in first" aspect and the experimental development aspects made Google so great - I can't help wondering if one day they go totally Apple and even remove the ability to customise their products so much; which is my favourite thing about them.
    :(

    I just think of them as additional settings, so as longer as the functionality remains, I'm not bothered.

    Google+): looks like a sad mermaid.

    NOOOOOO

    google labs was one of the best things about google's plans and rollouts. This is SO disappointing.

    Google, you've moved a few steps backwards today.

Join the discussion!

Trending Stories Right Now