Should You Dispute A Speeding Fine? This App Tells You

Dispute It is a free legal chat bot for motorists that has been designed to answer that age-old question: “is this fine worth challenging in court?” The app automatically compares the details of your case with scenarios where a review could be considered. It even provides sample wording and templates for your appeal and advice on what to do next.

Our Ask Lifehacker series receives more questions about speeding and parking fines than pretty much any other topic. Usually, the question centres on whether a penalty was justified and the likelihood of having it quashed in court. This is where Dispute It aims to help.

Designed by a group of Australian coders fronted by Queenslander Scott Bradley, the app takes the details of your fine and assesses the likelihood of a successful appeal, based on each state’s debt recovery office guidelines.

If there is a scenario where a appeal may be considered, the app tells you everything you need to know. According to Scott, the app is capable of the following:

  • identifying scenarios where a review may be considered
  • suggesting what proof would need to be sent with the appeal
  • providing sample wording & templates for your appeal
  • giving advice on how to go about the appeal

“Our chat bot clearly shows what scenarios [debt recovery officers] consider for review and what proof would have to be supplied with it,” Bradley explained to Lifehacker. “All the robot lawyer does is give the same info but presents it in a question and answer format and also gives sample text to use with the dispute.”

The app is pretty straightforward to use: you simply click on the options that relate to your fine and the bot spits out the rest.

Here’s a sample response to my (fictional) speeding fine in NSW that was issued by a police officer and followed up by an enforcement order:

  • As you have received an enforcement order at this stage your options are to dispute the fine in court or to pay and dispute it within 60 days of paying.
  • You do not have to have a lawyer if you elect to go to court, however, it is not always easy to represent yourself and even simple cases can sometimes raise complex legal issues.
  • Sometimes what you think is a defence is only an explanation, which means you are still guilty of the offence. Before you elect to go to court, you should get legal advice.
  • If you go to court, the court can give you a higher fine. You may also have to pay a court costs levy, a victims support levy and the legal costs of the prosecutor.
  • If you decide to pay but would still like assistance with disputing it start the chat process again but don’t say you have received an enforcement order.

Not bad for a free service, right? As with any automated online service, it goes without saying that you should not rely on it as a substitute for professional legal advice.

But as a starting point, it’s pretty damn great and will hopefully stop people from writing in to us. (There are only so many times we can answer the same question!)


The Cheapest NBN 50 Plans

Here are the cheapest plans available for Australia’s most popular NBN speed tier.

At Lifehacker, we independently select and write about stuff we love and think you'll like too. We have affiliate and advertising partnerships, which means we may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page. BTW – prices are accurate and items in stock at the time of posting.