Smartphone Showdown: Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge Vs HTC 10 Vs LG G5

LG, Samsung and HTC have released their new flagship smartphones for the first half of 2016. They're all pretty great — but which one is best? That largely depends on what you look for in a smartphone. We compare the Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge, HTC 10 and LG G5 to help indecisive Android fans make the right decision.

After years of uninspired upgrades and identikit models, the Android landscape is finally getting interesting again. The latest flagships from Samsung, HTC and LG are not just the same phone with different branding. Each handset has its own unique strengths and weaknesses which makes choosing the right one more difficult than usual.

We're going to take a look at each in turn — but first, here's how the specifications compare:

HTC 10 Galaxy S7 edge LG G5
OS Android 6.0 (Marshmallow) Android 6.0 (Marshmallow) Android 6.0 (Marshmallow)
Dimensions 145.9 x 71.9 x 9.0mm 150.9 x 72.6 x 7.7mm 149.4mm x 73.9mm x 7.7-8.6mm
Weight 161g 157g 159g
CPU Qualcomm Snapdragon 820 Processor Exynos 8890 Octa-Core Processor (2.3GHz, 1.6GHz ) Qualcomm Snapdragon 820 Processor
Memory 4GB RAM 4GB RAM (LPDDR4) 4GB RAM
Storage 32GB (+ MicroSD card slot) 32GB (+ MicroSD card slot) 32GB (+ MicroSD card slot)
Display 5.2 inch Quad HD IPS Quantum Display 5.5-inch Quad HD AMOLED 5.3-inch Quad HD IPS Quantum Display
Resolution 2560 x 1440 (577 ppi) 2560 x 1440 (534 ppi) 2560 x 1440 (554 ppi)
Camera 12MP (1.55μm pixel) rear camera / 5MP (1.34μm pixels) front camera 12MP rear, 5MP front 16MP rear camera (standard) / 8MP (Wide), 8MP front
Battery 3000mAh (non-removable) 3600mAh (non-removable) 2800mAh (removeable)
Charger USB Type-C USB 2.0 USB Type-C
Waterproofing No Yes (IP68) No
Price $1099 $1249 $1099

Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge

Not to be confused with the similarly named Samsung Galaxy S7, the S7 Edge comes with a larger display, longer-lasting battery and some additional software features. Otherwise, it's practically a twin to its sibling. It boasts a 5.5-inch 534ppi Super AMOLED display with a native resolution of 560x1440 pixels, a Exynos 8890 octa-core processor, 4GB of fast LPDDR4 RAM, a 12-megapixel rear-facing camera, a 3600 mAh battery and a MicroSD card slot; something that the S6 controversially lacked. It run on Android Marshmallow with Samsung's TouchWiz skin over the top.

Other noteworthy specs include IP68 water resistance (up to 30 minutes submerged in fresh water), dustproofing, inbuilt NFC, eventual Samsung Pay functionality and wireless charging. It's also bloody gorgeous, with a choice of Black Onyx, Gold Platinum and Silver Titanium finishes.

The S7 Edge's CPU, designed in-house by Samsung, boasts four cores running at up to 2.6GHz and four ARM Cortex-A53 cores running at up to 1.6GHz. It also comes with an LTE Category 12/13 modem that supports theoretical 4G download speeds of 600Mbps and upload speeds of 150Mbps.

The S7 Edge's 12-megapixel camera comes with a 1.4um-pixel sensor and f/1.7 aperture lens which translates to highly detailed photos; even in low lighting. Auto focus, which is the setting most users will stick to, is fast and reliable thanks to the phase detection point attached to each pixel.

One criticism that has been levelled at the S Edge is its temperature: the all-glass display has a tendency to heat up when the CPU is under load. It won't burn you, but it can get slightly uncomfortable; especially on hot days when you're hands are already sweating. While vastly improved compared to previous iterations, Samsung's TouchWiz skin can still occasionally get in the way. If you want a lightning quick and bare-bones OS, go for a Nexus.

Pros: Great camera, water resistant, sleek design.

Cons: Device heats up, lacks USB Type-C, pricier than competition.

HTC 10

The HTC 10 is a 5.2-inch Android smartphone powered by a current-gen Qualcomm Snapdragon 820 processor and 4GB of RAM running Android 6.0 (Marshmallow). It sports a 5.2-inch Quad HD display with a native resolution of 2560×1440 pixels and a 3000mAh battery that promises to deliver up to two days of battery life. Its Android skin was designed in direct partnership Google, translating to a faster, bloat-free UI.

Other noteworthy specs include a microSD card slot, a customisable audio profile with Airplay certification, a redesigned UltraPixel camera that HTC is billing as the best in the world. (It comes with a 12-megapixel sensor with 1.55um pixels, a f/1.8 lens aperture and optical image stabilisation.) Of the three phones featured here, we prefer the build quality of the HTC 10: its all-metal finish and deep-chamfered edges look and feel great.

The HTC 10 is powered by a Qualcomm Snapdragon 820 quad-core and 4GB of RAM. The new system-on-a-chip is based on a 64-bit quad-core Kyro processor, which clocks in at 2.2GHz. There's also an Adreno 530 GPU optimised for 4K video playback. It supports over 30 different frequency bands including all major 3G and 4G networks.

HTC reckons its smartphone's camera is the best in the world. It boasts a 12-megapixel sensor with 1.55um pixels, a f/1.8 lens aperture and optical image stabilisation. The phone also allows you to shoot and store high-resolution RAW images inside Google Photos.

While it performs very well in low-light situations, we'd hesitate to say it's in a class of its own. In real world testing, the Galaxy S7 Edge and LG G5 are every bit as accomplished. With that said, the 10 has an excellent front camera with a 5-megapixel 1.4um sensor, a f/1.8 wide-angle lens and optical image stabilisation — a first for a front-facing camera. If you regularly use your front camera for selfies and the like, HTC's lofty claims begin to ring true.

The HTC 10's bloat-free design can be a double-edged sword: there's no infra-red functionality, no wireless charging and no waterproofing. These features will doubtlessly be useful to some.

Pros: Great front-facing camera, excellent build, lots of audio options, fast performance.

Cons: Light on extra features.

LG G5

The LG G5 is powered by a current-gen Snapdragon 820 processor and 4GB of RAM running Android Marshmallow. It's biggest claim to fame is its unique modular design and host of snap-on peripherals (sold separately). Other noteworthy features include a 5.3-inch Quad HD IPS Quantum Display with a native resolution of 2560 x 1440 pixels (554ppi), a microSD card slot and — crucial for some — a removeable 2800mAh battery. It also comes with a 16-megapixel rear camera sporting dual lenses, one of which is wide-angle for superior framing.

In a bid to entice prospective customers, LG has announced it will replace broken screens free of charge, regardless of the cause. This will be a one-time offer, so accident-prone users will need to be vigilant after the first smash.

One of the best things about the LG G5 is its camera. Or rather, cameras. The LG G5 boasts a pair of snappers on the back: one 16-megapixel sensor behind a lens with a relatively standard 78-degree field of view, and one 8-megapixel sensor with a 135-degree super-wide-angle lens. The latter is perfect for true panorama shots that don't require separate images to be clumsily stitched together in-camera.

In addition to the handset, LG is selling a range of snap-on peripherals dubbed “friends”. These include the Cam Plus module (which adds a camera-style grip and physical controls), the 360 cam module (which adds two 13MP wide angle cameras, a 1200mAh battery and 4GB internal memory), B&O HI-FI Plus module (which adds a portable Hi-Fi DAC that supports 32-bit, 384KHz high-resolution audio playback), the Rolling Bot module (a camera-equipped BB8-style toy) and the Charging Kit module (which adds a dual function battery charging kit for other phones and tablets). All of the above modules will be available in May and will cost $129, $399, $229, $399 and $69.95, respectively.

On the downside, the LG G5 isn't our favourite looking phone. The unibody metal finish is perfectly functional, but we feel the HTC 10 and S7 Edge trump it in the looks department. It also comes with a smaller 2800mAh battery. While it can be swapped out for a larger one (something that isn't possible with the HTC 10 or Samsung S7), you're still stick with a weedier battery in the meantime.

Pros: Versatile camera, free screen replacement, removable battery.

Cons: Design could be better, some modules feel gimmicky.

Conclusion

It's going to sound like a cop-out, but all of these phones make for worthy purchases — the choice really comes down to personal preference. Do you go for the assured evolution of the Galaxy S7 Edge, the peerless build of the HTC 10 or the dare-to-be-different modular design of the LG G5?

For our money, the Samsung Galaxy S7 wins on the strength of its photographic output, beautiful design, vibrant screen and ability to be used underwater or in the shower. But it's a close thing. Tell us what you think on the comments.


Comments

    Give me the Huawei Mate 8. Been playing with one today at one of their Kiosks and it feels like a pretty solid unit. cheaper too.

    I had exactly this debate with myself a few months ago. The winner was the G5.

    Not that's there's much wrong with the others. But the cons for the others made my choice:
    S7
    1. Samsung make 3rd party development tricky with closed-source kernels
    2. They also tend to take ages to update OS versions (probably due to the need for TouchWiz compatibility)
    3. TouchWiz is still ugly and clunky. Although Samsung has made progress, it looks nothing like as clean and simple as native AOSP
    4. Samsung still insist on pre-loading bloatware replicating AOSP/Google apps. Although these system apps can be removed or disabled, it's not easy without root access and some know-how

    10:
    1. A backward step by aping Samsung's harware home button. There's no need for these since Android is designed for soft buttons.
    2. Having a capacitative home button ensures inadvertent presses when held in landscape orientation. At least Samsung's button is physical and requires pressure to push.
    3. Decrypting the data partition, it borks cellular connectivity. So no custom ROMs until someone finds a workaround.

    So why the G5? The changeable battery was appealing but I suspect in reality I won't use that feature. But mostly the fingerprint sensor on the back means that the phone unlocks when picked up one handed.

      There's already custom Roms for the HTC 10 as they have already found a workaround for the problematic partition.

      i wont buy a phone unless it has a hardware button on the front. so definitely not a con in my books.

    No mention of HTC 10 hi res dac support. It is also dust and splash proof.

    None. Google just buried them alive. All today phones are marked inadequate and non compatible by google. Smart move. 6 months in advance.

    When one considers the actual cost of production, including so called R&D and the fact that all these phones will be outdated in 6-9 months the prices are absurd. I would say 90% of users use less than 10% of the phones capabilities making buying one a waste of money.

Join the discussion!

Trending Stories Right Now