The Medical Screenings All Men Need, and When

The Medical Screenings All Men Need, and When

No matter how fast science develops new treatments, preventive medicine will always be the most effective and cheapest way to stay healthy. In a separate post, we shared the most common health screenings for women; today we’ll look at men’s health screenings: when you should get them, and what to expect when you do

Not surprisingly, men and women can look forward to different screening tests throughout their lifetimes. In today’s case we can solidly notch a point in the “better to be a man” column: There is only one recommended screening test for men of average risk (i.e. with no personal or family medical history).

That, of course, excludes routine things checked during your annual primary care visit (blood pressure, cholesterol, blood sugar, urinalysis, abdominal circumference, physical exam, etc.) or behaviour-related screenings (STIs, lung cancer). Those tests are all absolutely critical to maintaining your health — don’t skimp on them just because you think heart disease doesn’t seem as scary as colon cancer. But in terms of recommended screening for cancer and other diseases, you only have a colonoscopy to look forward to. Sad, I know.

As always, final decisions about your personal care should be made after a conversation between you and your physician, not after a quick perusal of the internet.

Colorectal cancer screening

What is it?

Most people associate colorectal cancer screening with colonoscopies — a multipurpose test that can screen for colorectal cancer, ulcers, polyps, and bleeding. There are actually a few methods of testing for colorectal cancer, each with a different screening recommendation. The unique advantage of the colonoscopy is that it visualizes the entire colon and allows for tissue sampling and removal of polyps as appropriate.

There are also several screening tests that look for blood in the stool, a possible sign of colon cancer.

What does it feel like?

For the colonoscopy and sigmoidoscopy prep, the almost universal response to that question was, “I don’t want to talk about it. There’s just so much poop.” For the colonoscopy itself, most people are sedated and have no memory of the experience, but because the sigmoidoscope does not travel as far up the digestive tract so patients are awake through the procedure. This was described as “someone is snaking a pipe…only it’s your rectum.”

For the faecal occult blood screening test (FOBT), your doctor will insert one lubricated, gloved finger into your rectum and test for blood (a digital rectal exam). This feels exactly as it sounds. For the faecal immunochemical test (FIT), you will collect samples of your own stool. This is painless, just kind of gross.

When should I get it?

The American Cancer Society (ACS) recommends four screening options for low risk men. In all cases, if a test is positive, further exam via colonoscopy is required. Doctors recommend screening beginning at age 50 or age 45 for African Americans. Patients can choose between a colonoscopy every 10 years, a flexible sigmoidoscopy every 5-10 years, CT colonography every 5 years, or double contrast barium enema every 5 years. The American College of Gastroenterology (ACG) emphasises that their preferred screening test for polyps and cancer is a colonoscopy.

For detection of cancer, ACS recommends either a Guaiac based faecal occult blood test or faecal immunochemical test every year, or a stool DNA test every three years. They do not consider in-office digital rectal exams to be a sufficient means of screening for cancer. Based on research suggesting FIT to be a superior test, it was adopted as the preferred cancer detection test by the ACG.

Prostate cancer screening

What is it?

Traditionally, men regularly receive a digital rectal exam (DRE) and Prostate Specific Antigen (PSA) test to screen for prostate cancer in patients without symptoms. During the DRE, the doctor inserts a gloved, lubricated finger into your rectum to feel for growths or bumps. The PSA is a blood test that looks for a protein produced by the prostate that may be elevated in cases of cancer.

What does it feel like?  

The doctor will typically have you bend over the table (there are other possible positions if you are are unable to stand that way) and insert their gloved finger into your rectum, probing around for any masses or anything out of the ordinary. The test will usually last under a minute, and while you may feel some mild discomfort, there shouldn’t be any pain. Awkward small talk may be involved. While they’re up there, many doctors will follow the exam with a FOBT to look for blood in your stool (a possible signifier of other, non-prostate cancer problems)

The PSA is a blood test, so that feels like a finger prick.

When should I get it?

Previously, PSAs were recommended yearly after 50 years of age, earlier for African American men and those with a family history of cancer. More recently, experts have recognised that the harms of this testing may outweigh the benefits. The PSA test may deliver falsely positive results (level elevated but no cancer), leading to unnecessary anxiety and additional testing. A positive PSA test may also find small tumours that are not causing symptoms, but this may not reduce the chances of dying from prostate cancer. The resulting over-treatment, which may include surgery or radiation, can result in potential harmful side effects and complications.

The American Academy of Family Physicians (AAFP) and ACS both recommend that physicians discuss the possible risks and benefits of testing with patients before making any decisions on testing. The discussion should start at age 50 for men of average risk, 45 for men of high risk, and 40 for those of very high risk. Screening is repeated annually or every two years, depending on the results. Testing for men with a less than 10 year life expectancy is not recommended by ACS.

The USPTF recommends against PSA testing for prostate cancer (these guidelines are currently being updated). For men who continue to request screening, they recommend doctors fully relay the risks and benefits of the procedure.

Penile cancer prevention

This last one is prevention rather than screening, but many men don’t realise that they are eligible for the HPV vaccine, so it’s worth mentioning here. It also protects against other forms of cancer, including cancers of the anus, mouth, and throat. “Penile cancer” just seemed like the most eye-catching header to go with here.

There are vaccinesGardasil and Cervarix — that protect against the cancer- and genital wart-causing strains of HPV. While earlier vaccination is ideal (it is recommended after age 11), the vaccine is recommended for women through the age of 26. This is a vaccine that prevents cancer. Man, woman, boy, girl — if you’re eligible and don’t have it, go get it.

Regular screening and early treatment of common medical conditions remains your best bet for reaching (or outliving!) the average American lifespan of 78.74 years (if you don’t live in the US, your average life expectancy can be found here).

This story was originally published in 2016 and updated in August 2020 for clarity, to replace broken links and to adhere to current Lifehacker style guidelines.


Leave a Reply