It can be tempting to buy a knife block, or buy a set for a friend who’s into cooking as a housewarming gift. Don’t do it. The money you spend on a knife set packed with subpar knives could be used to buy fewer excellent knives that will last a lifetime. Here’s why you should steer clear, and what you — or your aspiring chef friend — should own instead.
Knife Sets Almost Always Mean Terrible Knives
Especially when you’re just moving out on your own or setting up a kitchen, buying a set of knives can seem like a good idea. For a decent price, you can get a bunch of knives, a honing steel and a block to store them all in. Sounds good, right? The problem with knife sets is that they’re almost universally terrible. We touched on this a little bit before, but often manufacturers skimp on build quality, materials, size, and even blade geometry in some cases in order to produce a cheap product. They’re not designed to keep their edge in day-to-day use, to stand up to regular honings or even sharpenings, and they’re not designed to last. The video above from the folks at America’s Test Kitchen actually puts several sets to the test and reinforces the point.
Knife sets are often packed with redundant knives you’ll never use, and maybe one or two you’ll use until it’s dull, when it becomes more of a hazard than a help. Even the ones you use may be poorly designed for their purpose. The serrated knives in knife sets are often too short, the “paring” knives or “utility” knives in knife sets are almost always too short for actual peeling or detailed use, and don’t forget the annoyance that comes with opening an “eight piece knife set” only to find out that two of the “pieces” are the knife block and the honing steel in the centre, and you actually got six actual knives.
Long story short, for the money you spend on a knife set from a department or big box store, you can easily buy two or three great, versatile knives that will stand the test of time and keep their edge over regular, day-to-day use. After all, if you’re buying a set of eight — or, rather, six knives and only using two or three of them anyway — wouldn’t it be better to save money and get two or three amazing knives instead?
The Knives You Need In Your Kitchen (and Should Buy Instead)
The “right” knives for your kitchen depends on the type of cooking you do, of course. However, there are a few multi-purpose knives that every home cook should have, just because they’re good at just about anything you throw at them. Here are the essentials you should definitely own:
- A 20cm or 25cm Chef’s Knife: Whether you get a 20cm or 25cm one depends entirely on your kitchen working space and how comfortable you are with that size of knife. For me, I prefer a 20cm knife unless I’m working with larger cuts of meat or thick-rinded vegetables, in which case the added length and leverage of a 25cm chef’s knife can make a huge difference. You’ve heard us mention it before, but the Victorinox Fibrox 8″ is a knife that punches way above its weight here, and the 10″ Mercer Culinary is no slouch either.
- An 8cm or 10cm Paring Knife: From peeling vegetables and fruit to general light-duty jobs you don’t want to drag out a chef’s knife for, a good paring knife will probably be your go-to for just about anything that you say “I need a knife for this” but don’t need a huge, sharp, dangerous knife for. You know the jobs. America’s Test Kitchen likes the Wustof Classic 3.5″ Paring Knife, but if you’re sensing a theme, the Victorinox Swiss Classic Paring Knife is a good second choice. You could argue that a peeler makes a paring knife useless, but I find them way too versatile to omit (and learning to peel with a knife is a good skill to have.)
- A Long, Serrated Bread Knife: You might think that you can get away without a serrated utility or bread knife, and you probably could, but once you have one you’ll wonder how you lived without it. They’re not just for cutting bread either — they’re also perfect for easily cutting through sandwiches, cuts of fatty meat, tomatoes, peaches, or just about anything else that’s firm on the outside and soft on the inside — or that has a body that can tear easily. You’ll want at least 25cm of blade on your serrated knife and a little flexibility, as this America’s Test Kitchen review explains in detail Again, the 10″ Victorinox Bread Knife was one of their favourite budget picks, delivering clean cuts, with a long handle for easy grip. If you have cash though, the Wustof 10″Classic Bread Knife was their clear favourite, but spending that much defeats the purpose of ditching a knife block and picking up good affordable knives instead, so we’re going with the budget pick here.
- An 18cm or 20cm Santoku: This is a bit of a personal choice, because I actually prefer the way that a Santoku handles compared to a chef’s knife for many tasks — usually for multipurpose slicing and for cutting vegetables, but I’ve found the Santoku’s snub-curved blade at the front of the knife and shorter body makes precision slicing and thin cuts easier for me. You may or may not agree, but I definitely have times when I prefer my Santoku to my Chef’s Knife, and vice versa. Mercer Culinary’s 18cm Santoku knife is a sharp budget option.
In Alton Brown’s Gear for Your Kitchen, he starts with most of these (sans Santoku, of course) and then explains where you should go from there, and offers a few knife suggestions of his own, if you’d like to read more. Similarly, our list of essentials is a little different from the one our friends at Gizmodo put together, mostly because we’re aiming at essentials — knives you could easily buy with the money you saved on that knife block that’s on sale at your local department store.
The Knives You May Not Need, but Will Eventually Want
Speaking of Gizmodo’s list, once you have the knives above, here are some additional knives that you don’t need to have, but will certainly make specific tasks much much easier:
- A Carving or Slicing Knife: Don’t mistake this for a bread knife — a long, flexible, non-serrated blade like this Victorinox 10″ slicing knife can mean the world between nice, even slices of ham, roast or corned beef, cake, or just about any solid-but-large hunk of food where you want even slices without tearing up the body with a serrated blade. You won’t carve poultry with one of these (you’ll probably use a chef’s knife, since the pointed tip is useful for getting between bones and joints.) However, anywhere else where a single, slicing motion is enough to cut through the entire thing — or where you need the length of a serrated knife without the pesky teeth — this is your go-to blade. Getting one was one of the best things I’ve done.
- A Meat Cleaver: Lots of lists include the meat cleaver as an essential, and we can kind of understand why, but it’s probably not required for someone on a budget or just getting started in the kitchen. You’ll probably have better control and leverage with a chef’s knife for those times you may be tempted to use a cleaver, and if you run into that many situations where a cleaver would be better, you probably know you need one anyway. Still, once you have the basics down, one of these can be a big help. For the adventurous, a Chinese cleaver that’s designed for both chopping and delicate slicing (compared to a heavier European-style meat cleaver) can pull triple duty in your kitchen for vegetable chopping and dicing (once you know your way around with one, finely chopping even dense vegetables like cabbages and carrots is a breeze), an impromptu bench scraper, and hammering through bones and joints of large cuts of meat. This KitchenAid Classic 6″ cleaver is a good option for the more traditional cook.
- A Fillet or Boning Knife: Once you get in the habit of filleting your own fish or cutting up your own chicken, you’ll probably eventually want one of these. The super-thin, narrow, flexible blade makes it easy to slip in between bones and joints in a way you just can’t do with a chef’s knife. Even if you’re not interested in boning your own fish or parting out a chicken, these knives are great for trimming the silverskin or excess fat from large cuts of meat, or trimming off thin skin from large fruits and veggies without forcing you to grab your (often shorter) paring knife. America’s Test KItchen and Cook’s Illustrated prefer the 6″ Victorinox Fibrox Boning Knife.
- A Pair of Kitchen Shears: There’s a strong case to be made that these should be in the essentials list, but at some point or another, whether you need leverage getting through a joint when you’re parting our poultry, trimming or cutting stems, or you just need a versatile pair of scissors for opening packages, you’ll want kitchen shears. Ideally, you’ll want a pair that can be easily washed, that come apart into two pieces (but not so easily they will fall apart while you use them), and are easy to handle and grip even when your hands are messy. Henckels’ Take Apart Kitchen Shears are a good option, as are the Victorinox Kitchen Scissors. America’s Test Kitchen also recommends the Messermeister 8.5″ Take Apart Shears if you like the design and need more leverage (although lefties may not like them very much).
If you’re tempted to buy a knife set for a friend — as a housewarming gift or a wedding present — do them a favour and assemble a “dream team” of some of these knives instead and pack them together yourself, maybe along with a nice honing steel like this 12″ WINCO model, or this Victorinox sharpening steel. Trust us, your recipient will appreciate it more, and your gift will never collect dust in a cabinet somewhere. A whetstone set is also a great gift option for keeping their blades sharp.
You could go crazy and get all of these — even the budget options — and spend way more than a knife set at your local department store. We get that, but if you stick to the essentials and go with the bang-for-the-buck options listed here, you’ll probably spend less and wind up with knives that will last you much, much longer and hold their edge longer before you need to sharpen them (or have them sharpened.) While you’re at it, make sure to store them on a magnetic knife rack, or at the very least somewhere not in the utensil drawer. Your knives will stay happy, you’ll have the tools for whatever you want to cook, you’ll have saved a bunch of money, and most importantly, you’ll be safe in the kitchen.
This story has been updated since its original publication.