How to Make Perfect Mashed Potatoes, Every Time

How to Make Perfect Mashed Potatoes, Every Time

Mashed potatoes are one of those seemingly simple dishes that are well-loved by many. (Just thinking about it makes me feel comforted.) But take a few wrong turns in your mash prep, and you can very easily land yourself in mashed potato disaster territory. Icky texture. Bland taste. Watery consistency, even.

If you want to get your mashed potatoes right every time, there are a few rules you need to stick to. Here’s what they are:

Pick the right potato

For fluffy smashed spuds, you want a starchy, not waxy potato, like Sebago, Coliban or Desiree. You can mix varieties, but personally, I favour an all-Sebago situation because they are cheap, ubiquitous and grab onto fatty ingredients enthusiastically.

Dry ’em out a bit

After draining your potatoes, return them to the hot pan and cook for a couple of minutes to drive off any excess water, because watery mashed potatoes are no fun at all.

Stay out of the cold

You want your butter to be room temperature, and your milk to be warm. Cold ingredients aren’t the end of the world but they will cool down your mash and require more agitation to get fully incorporated, and too much agitation can lead to glue-y potatoes.

Infuse your dairy

How to Make Perfect Mashed Potatoes, Every Time

Rather than toss a bunch of raw, chopped herbs in at the end, place a couple of sprigs of thyme or rosemary in your milk or cream, and let it infuse over low heat while your potatoes boil.

Never, ever use a food processor

Do you want a pile of potato glop? If yes, try mashing your potatoes in a food processor, which will obliterate the starch granules and leave you with a glue-y pile of spud muck that is the opposite of the fluffy spuds you crave.

Use the ricer wisely

I am not a fan of ricing super starchy potatoes. They come out lump-free to be sure, but the mouthfeel veers dangerously close to that of instant. As such, I reserve my ricer for waxier potatoes, and use a regular masher on the starchy guys, which come out fluffy and virtually lump-free without any ricing.

Salt your cooking water

As with pasta, adding salt at the end is not enough for properly seasoned spuds. Season your cooking water just as you would with spaghetti, so that it is “salty like the sea”.

Add a bit of mayo

I know there’s going to be some knee-jerk, anti-mayo backlash to this, but trust me when I say that a few tablespoons of this excellent emulsifier will up the creaminess factor in your mash like you wouldn’t believe. (Also, you won’t be able to taste it. My stepmom has been adding mayonnaise to our mashed potatoes since I was a child, and I didn’t know until 2016.)

As far as recipes go, I like to keep it simple. To make fluffy, velvety smashed spuds, you will need:

  • 900g of potatoes
  • 1/2 full-cream milk
  • 1/4 cup of salted butter, at room temperature
  • 3 tablespoons mayonnaise (optional)
  • A couple of sprigs of fresh herbs, such as thyme or rosemary

Bring a large pot of very salted water to boil and add the washed and peeled potatoes that have been cut into fairly uniform, approximately 3cm chunks. While the potatoes are cooking, heat your milk (with herbs or without) over low heat, stirring occasionally so a skin doesn’t form.

Let the potatoes boil until a thin knife can pierce a chunk with barely any effort on your part, then drain the water off in a colander.

Reduce the heat to medium-low, and return the potatoes to the pot, cooking and stirring them for a few minutes to drive off excess water. Give the potatoes a few mashes with a potato masher (or use a ricer for waxy potatoes), then add your warm milk, butter and mayo (if using).

Give everything another couple of mashes, then stir with a wooden spoon to smooth everything out. Taste, season with salt and pepper if needed, and serve immediately with even more butter.

This story has been updated since its previous publication.

The Cheapest NBN 50 Plans

Here are the cheapest plans available for Australia’s most popular NBN speed tier.

At Lifehacker, we independently select and write about stuff we love and think you'll like too. We have affiliate and advertising partnerships, which means we may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page. BTW – prices are accurate and items in stock at the time of posting.


3 responses to “How to Make Perfect Mashed Potatoes, Every Time”