Lovehacker: My Boyfriend Wants Me To Peg Him. Is He Gay?

Lovehacker: My Boyfriend Wants Me To Peg Him. Is He Gay?

Dear Lovehacker, My boyfriend and I are trying to be more sexually adventurous and he suggested trying “pegging”. Should I be worried about him being secretly gay? Thanks, Peggy.

Hi Peggy,

I had a secretly gay boyfriend once, and pegging had nothing to do with it. He reacted by developing a penchant. But that’s a story for another time.

Male heterosexuality in the modern age is complicated. Hell, sexuality in general is. Just because your man wants you to don a strap on doesn’t mean that he likes dick.

It’s a shame, really. The misconceptions surrounding arse play means that many men are too intimidated to explore it, lest they be labelled homosexual.

This sexual stigma is so deeply ingrained in society that it’s barely even talked about. It’s the ultimate taboo. The only time it enters the cultural vernacular is when shows like Broad City have the guts to make it a part of the conversation. Incidentally, it worked and the media ate it up.

But let’s get real. I’ve done it.

One of my exes wanted to explore pegging, and I was really apprehensive at first. I wasn’t worried about his sexuality, rather the change in dynamic. For him, it was a power reversal fantasy and I didn’t know if I had what it takes to be in control like that.

You know what? It was mind blowing.

You may think you’re taking charge when you’re on top or tying a man up, but for me, none of it compared to actual penetration. You would not believe how confident and powerful you feel.

I thought that wearing silicone genitalia would feel silly at best, and unnatural and unfeminine at worst.

I couldn’t have been more wrong. I felt strong, confident and sexy – and he noticed. It was a turn on for him to have me take charge of the situation both physically and mentally.

The experience also brought us a degree of intimacy that I didn’t expect. I don’t know if it was the act of penetration or the fact that he could understand sex from a female perspective a little clearer, but it brought us closer together.

The fact that he feels comfortable enough to discuss this with you is a really positive sign. He clearly trusts you, which is significant considering that it’s such a delicate topic. This bodes well for the future of your relationship.

And let’s not forget that guys love sex and orgasms. The anus can produce an extraordinary amount of pleasure for men thanks to the prostate gland. Queer gentlemen don’t just bang this way because it’s the only available hole — it also feels really good. Some even say it’s the ultimate orgasmic experience for a guy.

If your boyfriend is confident enough in his sexuality to want to experience this, good for him. I say go for it.

If you don’t want to dive right in, maybe try experimenting first. See how you both feel about a finger or two before working your way up.

Who knows, perhaps it will become so ingrained in your sexual roster that it will be fun to see how much he can end up taking.

Lovehacker is a weekly relationship and sex column where our resident Agony Aunt answers your questions. Need help? Drop a comment below or email [email protected].


  • “I reacted by accidentally making out with a mental patient.” – Not going to lie, I’m curious now…

    • @luffy_luck It’s a pretty great story! The humiliation of 19-Year-Old-Tegan is Present-Tegan’s gain!

  • I have thought about recieving Anal play and pegging for years but could never ask my now ex partner as I don’t think she would of taken it well.

    Since we separated I have tried some Anal play with another women and it is fantastic. I am generally quitish when I have sex, but I was moaning like crazy. It is a completely different climax. So much more intense and lasted a lot longer.

    Don’t be shy about your sexuality. It does not make you gay.

  • there is nothing normal about pegging, find out why this appeals to him and then decide if he has mental issues or not, and whether you are ok with it

    I would not ask a chicken farmer if meat tastes good, you’re just not going to get a meaningful answer

    your gut reaction was negative, and it’s there for a reason
    people need to stop saying yes to things they do not like

    whats next?
    “should I be ok with my husband sleeping around as long as he comes home?”
    should we be tolerant of all behaviours?

    • No one said say yes to things you don’t like, the answer was don’t assume this means what you think it does and consider it without the stigma attached, then sharing a positive experience. It wasn’t a command, it was a sales pitch.

    • should we be tolerant of all behaviours?
      Depends on the behaviour in question. What’s so wrong with this one?

    • Sounds like you’ve been on the receiving end of the sleeping around question before… here’s some more food for thought:

      Is going down on a girl gay? because thats what lesbians do
      Is giving anal to a girl gay? because anal is what homos do

      The very base definition has nothing to do with sex, its who you’re attracted to, are you aroused by naked girls or naked guys? Got that part worked out? Cool, now enjoy your body however you want.

  • Having something up your butt tickling that gland doesn’t make you gay, it just means you want something tickling that feeling-good gland. If it’s a male genitalia attached to a male, then you may be a bit more gay. But otherwise… 🙂

Show more comments

Comments are closed.

Log in to comment on this story!