Are The Crows In Dumbo Really That Racist?

Dear Lifehacker, One of my favourite animated movies growing up was Disney's Dumbo. My daughter just turned four and I want her to have the same magical experience watching it that I did. However, as an adult, I'm not entirely comfortable with the somewhat racist depiction of the anthropomorphised crows. Do you think I'm overacting, or should I censor this type of stuff from an impressionable child? Thanks, Inclusive Parent

Dear IP,

For those who somehow missed this film growing up, you can see some of the offending clips in the video below:

So are these silly cartoon hi-jinks racist? Yeah, probably.

The group of crows that assist the titular elephant in Dumbo are certainly controversial. When the movie was made in 1942 racism was still running rampant in the US and African Americans were strictly segregated from whites via the deeply discriminatory Jim Crow laws.

Meanwhile, the main crow character in Dumbo is literally called Jim Crow and was voiced by a white man (Cliff Edwards) "talkin' jive". This is basically the animated equivalent of a minstrel show. If that's not racist, I don't know what is.

On the other hand, the crows are among the few decent and intelligent characters that Dumbo meets on his journey. They genuinely care about Dumbo's plight, engage in witty wordplay and make their own decisions throughout the movie. There's certainly no hint of the servile Man Friday or "magical negro" in these characters. They walk to the beat of their own drum and don't get pushed around by anybody.

Plus, the rest of the crow gang were actually voiced by African Americans which was exceedingly rare for the time. Their memorable song When I See an Elephant Fly was performed by the all-black Hall Johnson Choir. (Mind you, this could have been preemptive damage control to ward off criticisms of racism.)

In any event, it can't be denied that the crows in Dumbo are problematic. They're also a product of their time which is something we shouldn't shy away from or pretend didn't happen.

Our advice is to watch Dumbo with your little one and enjoy it. When she's a bit older, gently explain why the crows might be deemed offensive by some people and why. In most cases, communication is vastly preferable to censorship.

On a semi-related note, you might want to skip the whole 'Pink Elephant' bit. While it's not racist, that shit was designed to give kids nightmares.

Cheers Lifehacker

Have a question you want to put to Ask Lifehacker? Send it using our contact form.

11 Scenes From 'Kids' Movies That Destroyed Us

Do you prefer a "gloves off" approach to raising your offspring? Are you sick of modern entertainment mollycoddling kids? Here are 11 scenes from "family friendly" movies and TV shows that will help toughen the little blighters up. (Alternatively, if you're an overprotective parent, here are eleven scenes that you absolutely must avoid at all costs.)

Read more


Comments

    I guess they could have made them white, but then they wouldn't be crows would they. Pointless article if you ask me.

    People cant be tried on laws that did not exist when the crime was committed. Why would movies be tried by standards which did not exist when they were created.

    Leave classics as classics. We do not want to be a nanny state

      work on your reading comprehension.
      no one said anything about changing anything.
      the question was whether or not their child should be exposed to racist material.
      the article wasn't pointless. the way art is viewed does change over time.
      the issue of "nanny state" politics is unrelated to actually raising a child.

        I hardly think the scene pictured above will cause your child to run outside and find the nearest black person and start screaming racial slurs.

    I look at it this way: I grew up with books filled with golliwogs and never once connected them with black people. They looked nothing like the black people I saw in picture books or in real life. Mind you, most of the non-black characters in children's books are pretty unusual in their appearance, dress, speech etc.

    I think kids will start differentiating between fantasy and reality, especially if we provide them a healthy dose of real positive models. They will be exposed to this sooner or later. Start them young, and be ready to answer their questions.

    Yeah, you really need to pay attention to the advice on the Pink Elephant scene.
    That shit definitely freaked me out as a kid.

    Isn't the real racism the person viewing the film. They are crows not black people if the viewer associates them as being black aren't they then the ones who are racist. What human race equivalent is Dumbo?

    This is not the correct advice. We are constantly surrounded by racist images and reinforcement of stereotypes that we all personally have to fight against. We should not knowingly expose our children to racist views and stereotypes. Plus the song in Dumbo is also super problematic problematic.

Join the discussion!

Trending Stories Right Now