Under most circumstances, you wouldn't go looking for broken things at a garage sale or second-hand shop. Unless they're damaged tools from companies like Ridgid. Then you might be able to exchange them for all new ones. Photo by darkday.
As reddit user BFranklin1706 points out, many tools from companies like Ridgid have lifetime warranties that guarantee replacements if the tool is damaged from normal use. If you have a broken tool, you can take it to a service centre and potentially walk out with a brand new or even lightly used replacement. Your experience may depend on just how damaged the tool is, or the manager at your store, but it's worth taking a look when you're in the market for new tools.
Lifehacker's Workshop column covers DIY tips, techniques and projects.