Use The Straw Man Tactic To Ease The Blow When Giving Criticism  

Use The Straw Man Tactic To Ease The Blow When Giving Criticism  
Facebook may have decided that you shouldn’t see the news, but we think you deserve to be in the know with Lifehacker Australia’s content. To sign up for our daily newsletter covering the latest news, hacks and reviews, head HERE. For a running feed of all our stories, follow us on Twitter HERE. Or you can bookmark the Lifehacker Australia homepage to visit whenever you need a fix.

In an argument, the “straw man” tactic is used to set up a poor representation of your opponent’s opinion and attack that to undermine them. It’s a pretty crappy way to have an argument. If you’re trying to give constructive criticism, however, you can use it to help avoid hurt feelings.

Photo by Peter Pearson.

As business blog Entrepreneur points out, when someone is receiving criticism, they can end up feeling emotionally threatened or get defensive. Even if your advice means well (or you’re a boss that has to give that feedback), emotions can complicate an otherwise helpful discussion. Instead of directing the criticism at the person themselves, set up a straw man target:

If someone feels personally threatened by what you are saying, his or her defences will go up and he or she won’t be able to internalize your criticism. Try to give the critique through a personal anecdote or an inspiring story of someone famous who went through the same thing. It’s so much easier to swallow when it’s not straight out about “you” and “your” mistakes.

As an example, say you have a friend who wants to start a side business, but doesn’t have a business plan. Rather than saying “You’re not going to get anywhere until you have a business plan in place,” you can relay that same information by saying “The most successful people I know who have started a side business had a business plan in place. Maybe you could start there?”

Also, keep in mind that this method is necessarily less confrontational. Using this tactic to avoid having a tough conversation where you need to be direct may not be the best idea. Try not to use it just to avoid having to say “Hey you were a jerk last night.” However, for light criticism that doesn’t need to be personal, it can be very useful.

5 Steps to Providing Constructive Criticism [Entrepreneur]


  • I’m not sure this counts as a straw man. I thought a straw man was something like:

    Person A: I don’t think charging people who are found with small amount of illicit drugs is a sensible way to combat the drug problem.

    Person B: Allowing people access to any drug they want and letting people to use it whenever they want would be disastrous for a society! We’d be awash with drugs and people would be driving and working stoned!

    Person B fails to address persons A’s position by entirely misrepresenting it. I thought that was a straw man. The example in the article just seems to be a polite or constructive way to offer advice. I don’t understand how it relates to straw man fallacies.

Comments are closed.

Log in to comment on this story!