Ask LH: Is There A Cheap Way To Own Two Cars?

Dear Lifehacker, Is it possible to cheaply own a second car? I'm not so concerned about purchase price and petrol. I'm more worried about CTP, rego and comprehensive insurance options. This is just a car for occasional use by my wife, so $1250 a year minimum (my estimates for NSW) before it even leaves the driveway seems a bit much. Are there options for low-cost low-mileage small vehicles that aren't so expensive? (We're both well over 30) Cheers, Family Guy

Cars picture from Shutterstock

Dear FG,

Unfortunately, the amount of driving you do isn't factored into your annual registration fee. You can take your car on 50 epic road trips or leave it in the garage all year: either way, the rego will be the same. (In the former case, actually passing registration could be a bigger challenge, however.)

Naturally, there's a lot more variation when it comes to compulsory third-party insurance and related costs. We passed your query over to Gizmodo's resident car expert Campbell Simpson. Here's what he came back with:

Is there a cheap way to own two cars? The short answer is not really. There's a certain sunk cost in having a second car, and like you've realised, a lot of that is in the fact that there are some mandatory costs that aren't avoidable.   The problem with CTP is that -- for the most part -- it's a fixed price, based on the age of the vehicle as well as a few other factors like the age of the youngest driver, that driver's previous driving record, and the postcode that the vehicle is garaged in. Unless there's an outlier -- in this example, with a MY2000 car in Sydney driven by a 30-year-old driver with a perfect record, QBE is $250 cheaper than the others' approximately $850 quotes -- you'll almost certainly be paying a relatively fixed cost. The same is true of registration.   Non-compulsory insurances like third party property damage, third party plus fire and theft, and comprehensive insurance are much more variable, and can be adjusted significantly depending on your suburb, your driving history and also the vehicle that you purchase. As a general rule, older cars are more expensive to insure because they're a larger crash risk, and the same is true of sporty cars, younger drivers, and male drivers -- you might find a policy in your wife's name for a Corolla might be much cheaper than your name in a WRX of the same age or price. On a cheap, occasional use car, I wouldn't suggest comprehensive, purely because it's significantly more expensive, and the agreed value of the vehicle will likely be too low to make a repair feasible in the first place.   Where you can potentially save a little money is by bundling your policies with a single provider. NRMA, for example, offers a sliding loyalty discount that increases the longer you keep your policies, and also with the more policies overall. Using two cars for both CTP and non-compulsory insurance, you'll save 7.5 per cent overall. Again, there's a caveat in that the cheapest overall provider for one car's CTP or non-compulsory insurance might not be the cheapest for the other, and vice versa. Suffice to say, you might save a bit of money by bundling, or you might not.   If it's for genuinely occasional use, and you're living in a metropolitan area, a car-sharing service like GoGet or Hertz 24/7 or even Car Next Door might work out cheaper in the long run. When you consider that $1000-plus sunk cost of compulsory third party injury, third party property insurance and registration, maybe $500 of petrol per year, and a couple of hundred (at least) in maintenance -- mandatory, especially on an older car, not only to pass yearly inspections but to keep you and your wife safe as well as other road users -- you'll get yourself 30-odd full-day rentals of a GoGet or similar sharing car over each year.   If you're committed to the idea of owning two cars, the best thing I can suggest is to shop around, using a couple of different cars that you're potentially interested in buying, to see which is cheapest overall -- with the caveat that in some cases, you do get what you pay for, both for the car itself and the quality of the insurance.

Cheers Lifehacker

Have a question you want to put to Ask Lifehacker? Send it using our contact form.


Comments

    One of the best financial decisions my wife and I made was to consolidate our two old cars into one new car. In the past two years, I could count on two hands the number of times it's been a problem for us, and really if you have to drop $50 for a taxi a couple of times a year you still end up way ahead of the owning/maintaining a second car.

      This, but car+ motorcycle. Both have freedom, and my 1200cc brand new motorcycle still saves us bucketloads compared to another small car.

        +1 to the motorcycle. My V6 Outlander is a gas gusler and the trains cost too much.
        Cheaper to ride the motorbike in and park in secure parking! (Brisbane CBD anyway)

    If the use is really occasional, wouldn't it be cheaper and easier to use Taxis and/or short term car hire / car sharing options?
    You're paying $1250 / year + consumables + if you divide your car's purchase price over say 10 years, it is probably cheaper to rent a car for a few days a year when she really needs it.

    get a motorbike! You know you want to.....

      Agree. Car + motorbike works very well. The car for moving big things - and the bike for easy parking and going into the city. Thumbs up!

        I take the motorbike anywhere with pay parking haha. I've barely paid parking since I started riding ;)

    You forgot another option - buy an older car and get it on Historic Rego :P

    Buy two cars exactly the same. Re-stamp the VIN, Engine, and chassis numbers of car 1 onto car 2. Register & insure car 1. Report your plates lost / stolen / damaged. Get "replacement" plates and put them on car 2.

    Voila. 2 cars but only one set of rego, insurance and tolls :)

    *Note: You didn't ask "Is There A Cheap Way To Legally Own Two Cars"

    Last edited 20/08/15 6:25 pm

    I have 4...
    only 3 registered though...
    but, still expensive, 3k for rego, 3k for insurance...

    Hmm, I think you could own two cars on two separate capacities - personal and business. Especially if you need one for your spouse to run errands around town, that could be a good reason to ensure that you have a second car.

    I agree with the commenting on this. Sad to say, that there is a bit of an embedded rule that makes the administrative costs of owning a second car a bit higher. If you shop around and look at your financing rates, you can probably get a car for cheap, but it will almost never be as cheap as if it was your first car.

Join the discussion!