Hey Lifehacker, Recently I had a long-running warranty dispute with an electronics manufacturer. They "repaired" the item in question a few times but I was still having issues. In arranging a replacement, I had to sign and agree to not discuss the terms of the warranty with anyone but a lawyer. The provider claimed "neither party is responsible, but we are replacing the product to avoid ongoing dispute" in the paperwork.
Is this legal? I thought as a consumer you had every right to say what you like about a company if they did something wrong. Any advice?
Thanks Concerned Consumer
Ask Lifehacker is presented by Optus.
Find out how Optus can help you Live More Yes!
Under Australian consumer law, if a product has major continuing defects you're entitled to insist on a replacement or a refund. For minor faults, the provider is entitled to offer a repair, but continuing problems suggest a replacement is the appropriate remedy.
Under those circumstances, you shouldn't have to sign any special agreement in order to receive your rights. If a company suggested that, I would be heading straight to the relevant consumer affairs department in my state to resolve the issue.
The problem in this case is that you have already signed the agreement, which does mean for practical purposes you're bound by its terms. Chances are the organisation has better and more expensive lawyers than you, so if you do start badmouthing them online, the consequences might be unpleasant. The lesson? Don't sign such an agreement in the first place (and don't buy from that company ever again). Consumer rights aren't contingent on staying silent.
A side note: your right to highlight consumer issues online isn't limitless. In theory at least, defamation laws apply online as well — though tracking down anonymous posters is time-consuming, expensive and can often lead to the Streisand effect, where attempts to shut down discussion of an issue only end up making it more prominent.
Got your own question you want to put to Lifehacker? Send it using our contact form.
Contract picture from Shutterstock