How Your Car Is Making You Fatter

A new study has shown that travelling to work via public transport is healthier than using your car -- at least when it comes to your waistline. On average, people who drive to work tend to be around 3kg heavier than those whose commute is more active. In other words, that five-minute walk to the bus stop really does make a difference.

Photo: Shutterstock

Researchers from the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine analysed the health records of approximately 15,000 people based on a combination of BMI measurements and body fat measurements. This data was then compared to the participants' preferred mode of work travel.

A total of 76 per cent of men and 72 per cent of women commuted to work by private motorised transport, 10 per cent of men and 11 per cent of women reporting using public transport, while 14 per cent of men and 17 per cent of women walked or cycled.

The study found that men who take the car weigh an average of 3kg more than non-drivers, while female drivers tipped the scales by an additional 2.5kg. Interestingly, there was a marked difference in body weight among public transport users, not just cyclists and walkers:

In fully adjusted models the mean body mass index of men travelling to work by public transport was lower by 1.1 (95% confidence interval 0.5 to 1.7) than that of men using private transport. This benefit is likely to accrue because use of public transport generally involves walking to transport access points or interchanges, thus increasing incidental physical activity.

Based on its findings, the report suggests that healthcare professionals should begin advising patients to “leave your car at home” and increase the number of trips they make for work, shopping, and leisure using public transport.

"This will not only improve their patients’ health in the short term but also reduce the burden of obesity and related health conditions,” the report concludes. "It is crucial that the public health community provide strong and consistent messages to politicians and the public which frame these measures as positive public health actions.” Here's hoping the ebola epidemic doesn't prove them wrong.

Healthier Commuting: Leave Your Car At Home [BMJ]


Comments

    This is why I moved to an apartment in the city. It was far too much effort to walk anywhere in the suburbs, that's if anything was in walking distance. Now I walk pretty much anywhere. Plus when leaving by car I'm going against peak traffic, and parking is cheaper outside of the city when I leave!

      I do the same thing, except by bike. I cycle ~300km a week, in an average week. Save a bunch on fuel, that's for sure.

    By a foldable bike and take it on the train. That way you can ride a reasonable distance to the station and/or to the office from the station etc without necessarily working up an ugly sweat.

    Make public transport equal in price to travelling by car, and you got a deal

      PT is cheaper for me, considerably so.

      Public transport is heaps cheaper! Check out the RAC's vehichle running costs guide: http://rac.com.au/motoring/motoring-advice/buying-a-car/running-costs

      For a small car like a Civic or Cerato, bought new on finance, they reckon you'll pay about $8000 per year. But even if you assume the car is free and just look at fuel, maintenance, recommended servicing, rego, and insurance, the estimate comes out to just over $4000 per year. Four fucking thousand dollars per year!

      By contrast, a yearly zone 1 and 2 Myki pass is $2210. If you really need a car for couple of days during the year, you can rent one, and still be $1700 better off.

        Ok, make it cheaper in Queensland. With all running costs factored in, I'm looking at around $90 a week for myself to drive. That same train trip would cost me around $140.

        This excludes the loan repayments of $110 a week, but since I also have a passenger in the car doing the same trip, the driving cost is the same, but PT is double

Join the discussion!