How To Choose The Perfect Mouse And Keyboard

12
How To Choose The Perfect Mouse And Keyboard


Are you still using the mouse and keyboard that came with your computer? Or maybe you’ve tried something new but you’ve got some nagging RSI strain, cords tangled everywhere or a lagging mouse that’s left you unjustly fragged into oblivion? If your mouse and keyboard aren’t working for you, it’s time to buy new ones. Here are the things you’ll want to keep in mind as you shop.

Mice

There are some great cheap, simple, two-button mice out there, but you’d be surprised how much easier a nicer mouse can make your day. Sure, a nice mouse can be a bit pricier than the $20 two-buttoner you bought at Officeworks, but whether it’s getting rid of wrist pain or just saving you endless clicks on the scroll wheel, they’re well worth the money. In fact, the $US75 I spent on my mouse is some of the best money I’ve spent on my entire rig — and since you use these items every time you sit down at your machine, you should make sure they’re of good quality. If you’re ready to trade in the old beater for a new model, here are some things you’ll want to consider.

Size and Ergonomics

Undoubtedly the most important factor in choosing a mouse is how it feels. While you can prevent a lot of strain by merely rearranging your workspace, having a good mouse that works with you can still make a huge difference. For the most part, this involves two things: size and grip. Size is mostly personal preference (plus how portable you want your mouse to be), but certain mice are better for certain types of grips. The three main grips are:


Palm GripRazer LachesisMicrosoft IntelliMouse Explorer


Claw GripRazer DeathAdderLogitech G9xLogitech Performance Mouse MX


Fingertip GripRazer AbyssusLogitech Marathon Mouse M705

The above images are from Razer’s mouse ergonomics guide, which I recommend checking out. It’s mainly written for gamers but can apply to anyone. I also recommend checking out NCIX Tech Tips’ guide to mouse ergonomics if you want more information on figuring out your grip and what mice are good for it. Note also that the mice listed above are just guidelines. Everyone’s hands are different, and you probably use a combination of the above grips or lie somewhere in between. The size of your hands can also influence which types of mice work with which types of grips. If you have smaller than average hands, for example, don’t be afraid to venture outside the above recommendations to see if your claw grip works with a mouse designed for a palm grip. The best advice I can give is go to the store and try them out — these aren’t the kinds of things you can tell when ordering a mouse online.

Wired vs Wireless


Also keep in mind that if you’re going to go wireless, you have a few different choices — namely Bluetooth and RF. RF mice are usually a bit more responsive and have a longer range, but they require a USB receiver, so they’ll still take up a USB port on your machine. They’re also more likely to interfere with other wireless devices, as I mentioned before. Bluetooth mice are a bit rarer but will pair with many computers on their own (if your computer has Bluetooth built-in). Finding a good Bluetooth mouse can be hard, since RF is much more common — so unless you’re really short on USB ports, I wouldn’t recommend being too picky about Bluetooth versus RF.

Extra Buttons


to a function like Mac OS X’s Exposé

Sensitivity


Sensitivity is calculated in dots per inch (DPI). Most medium-end and high-end mice come with high sensitivities, usually 1200DPI or higher, which should be more than enough. Just make sure that you aren’t getting a cheap 400DPI mouse if you’re doing precision-oriented tasks. Some mice even have buttons on them that let you switch between different sensitivities without opening up their control panel, which is great if you want to quickly switch to a high sensitivity for image editing or gaming, then switch back when you go to do normal work.

What We Use

While we encourage you to do your own research and shopping, here are a few of the Lifehacker staff’s favourite mice to get you started:

  • At least four of us use the Logitech Performance Mouse MX (formerly known as the MX Revolution), and we’re all in love with it. It perfectly contours to your hand, has a few extra buttons that you can remap to whatever you want, and has the amazing momentum scrolling feature I mentioned earlier. While it’s designed for more of a palm or claw grip, it’ll really work with any grip you want, in my experience. This is a great place to start if you’re looking for a good wireless mouse (though it isn’t exactly portable, as it’s huge).
  • On the other end of the spectrum is the Microsoft Wireless Mouse 5000, which is Dachis’s favourite external mouse (he’s usually a trackpad kind of guy). It’s simple, inexpensive, wireless and portable enough to carry around with you.
  • For gaming, Jason is currently digging the Razer Naga, who’s main draw is a big panel of 12 — count them — thumb buttons. It’s designed for massively multiplayer games like World of Warcraft, but you can map them to functions in any game you want (or even on the desktop, if you’re the adventurous type).

Keyboards

While you primarily use keyboards for typing — and while a $20 keyboard will type just fine — they can do oh so much more. A nicer keyboard gives you extra buttons for quick media control, volume control or even app launching, and if you experience any RSI, a new keyboard can help eliminate that by forcing you to use good posture. When you’re ready to bite the bullet and pick up a new keyboard, here are some things to watch out for.

Ergonomics


Microsoft Natural Keyboard EliteLogitech K350

The other half of the ergonomic factor is the feel of the keys. Some keyboards have more traditional raised keys, though laptop-style keyboards are becoming very popular for desktops, like the Logitech DiNovo Edge or even chiclet-style keyboards, like those from Apple. If you have the money to spend, though, mechanical keyboards like the SteelSeries 6Gv2 have become very popular as of late — that is, keyboards with a mechanical spring inside instead of a rubber dome. These keyboards have a bit more resistance to the keys. It takes a bit more effort to press them down, and they’ll spring up faster, but overall they have a better and more consistent “feel” to the keys. They don’t wiggle around like traditional keyboards, and you’re less likely to get one key that sticks down more than the others. If you can find one to try out, it’s worth a look — many people who use mechanical keyboards say they’ll never go back to the standard rubber dome. They do tend to be a bit louder and more expensive, though, so keep that in mind as you shop.

Wired vs Wireless


looks

Extra Function Keys


create your own global keyboard shortcuts with something likeAutoHotkey

Other Considerations

Keyboards come with all sorts of different features these days, so it’s hard to cover them all here. For example, some keyboards come without number pads, some come with alternative keyboard layouts like Dvorak, and some even come with extra USB ports for your other peripherals. And if you’re a gamer, you have a whole other set of features to deal with, like add-on panels with gaming hotkeys and anti-ghosting features. Illuminated keys are also a popular feature for gamers, or just those that spend a lot of time in the dark. As with most hardware, the best thing you can do is shop around, and shop around in person. The more you can try out keyboards and get a “feel” for them, the more informed your decision will be. Don’t just tap on the keyboards, though, go through the kinds of actions you’d go through in a normal day. I’ll usually bang out a fake news article, pretend copy and paste some links with my remapped shortcuts, and move my hand between the mouse and keyboard to see if there are any annoyances that will drive me crazy after a few days of use. Plus, the more you shop around, the more you’ll discover new features like illuminated keys, which could change your decision significantly.

What We Use

Again, we encourage you to check out different models for yourself, but if you’re feeling a bit overwhelmed, here are some of our favourite keyboards:

  • Alan and both Adams are fans of Apple’s keyboards, for their low profiles and good key action. Despite what you think about Apple and their computers, their chiclet-style keyboards are actually pretty fantastic. The wired version even contains a USB port so they don’t “waste” one in your machine.
  • When gaming, Alan uses the Logitech G19, which has a ton of extra keys across the top that you can program to different actions in different games (or, again, actions on the desktop). It also has a handy little LCD that can display information in different games, which is super useful. Plus it lights up in different colours. How could you say no?
  • Jason’s a keyboard hoarder, but right now his favourite is the Microsoft Comfort Curve 3000, which he’s written about before. If you’re a sufferer of RSI, this is a great keyboard to check out. It’s got a nice ergonomic “wave” design that doesn’t feel awkward, but forces you to keep good keyboard posture.
  • I’ve used a few keyboards over the years, but I can’t pry myself away from Logitech’s slim-profile keyboards. As a guy who sits in the dark a lot, I’m currently loving the Logitech Illuminated Keyboard, which has just enough function keys to keep me happy. Logitech’s diNovo line is also great though, if you’re willing to spend a bit more money for a bunch of other functionality.

Remember, comfort and health comes first. You probably spend lots of time sitting at your desk with these peripherals, and the less likely you are to develop strain injury, the better — the rest is just a matter of convenience. Got any of your own favourite mouse and keyboard features (or just favourite models you want to share)? Sound off in the comments.

Comments

  • Some of your information about mechanical keyboards isn’t quite correct. Without going into too much detail:

    -Depending on what kind of switch the board has, the keys often require LESS force to register a key press than a typical rubber dome board. Cherry MX Red switches are extremely ‘light’ for example

    -Not all mechanical keyboards are noisy. Modern boards with Cherry MX Blue switches have a ‘click’ but other kinds aren’t noisy unless you ‘bottom out’ (press the key all the way down so it hits the bottom of the board, which isn’t needed for the key to register a key press)

    -Often, mechanical keyboards cost less than ‘high end’ rubber dome boards. Have a look at PC Case Gear’s range of keyboards and compare the prices of high end Logitech ‘gamer’ keyboards with the offerings from Leopold.

    -Oh, and just so you know the ‘perfect’ keyboard is the IBM Model M

    🙂

    • Replying to myself- I forgot to mention mice.

      At work, I don’t use a mouse any more. I’ve switched to a logitech wheel trackball. Not as much adjustment coming from a mouse as you would think, and much better for your hand/wrist for heavy usage.

      At home I still use a mouse, but that’s mainly for gaming.

  • Like Tom I have ditched my mouse completely (Did use the Logitech MX before – beautiful beast) for an Apple Trackpad. I find the gestures a great improvement to workflow and my hand doesn’t get as worn out. I find using a mouse quite quaint and archaic now.

    To compliment my hi-tech track pad I am still using my 1996 Model M13 keyboard – you can’t improve on perfection.

  • Are there any good wireless keyboards? I mean we’re living in the future but I can’t seem to find a wireless keyboard that doesn’t have an offensive design. I used a Razer Tarantula keyboard for years and hated the size of it so I’m hoping there’s some good ten-keyless options out there. The Happy Hacking Pro 2 looks beautiful, it’s price tag less so, but is there anything similar in the wireless realm?

  • MX Revolution is the best mouse I’ve ever used, bar none. Also used the MS Wireless Mouse 7000 at work for a while – that thing has absolutely phenomenal battery life.

    I use a Logitech G15 (orange) at home. Would be just as happy with the newer G11 (IIRC … the one without the screen) as I don’t really use the screen. But the macro keys, and the ability to create macros on the fly is suprisingly useful.

  • On the surface the Performance Mouse MX looks better than the Revolution, but it is inferior in multiple ways.

    My favourite is still the MX1100. More comfortable, more accurate and much less offensive design. The only downside is that it doesn’t work with unifying receivers, and the included receiver is about 1.5″ long. Fine for a desktop but not so much for a laptop.

  • I’m still using the MX Revolution combined with the MS Natural Ergonomic keyboard 4000. Both were quite expensive when I bought them a couple of years ago.. but worth every dollar. They are still functioning perfectly.

  • I’m not a gamer but found logitech’s mice fast scroll feature a killer for my uses. I’ve worn out about half a dozen “work” mice in the last 5 years.

    I do lots of data manipulation, spreadsheets and some graphics & sketch type work as a technical project manager – so I’m not using CAD or photo shop.

    My style is finger tip control for its preciseness.

    I found logitech’s v550 mouse fantastic:
    http://www.logitech.com/en-au/428/4611?WT.z_sp=Image

    This was so good I bought the bluetooth version for my home laptop:
    http://www.logitech.com/en-au/428/5747?WT.z_sp=Image

    Both have lasted very well compared to my previous hp, targus, belkin and kensington mice and happy to recommend them.

Log in to comment on this story!