Why Google Isn't Making You Stupid

Various studies and writers have convinced many of us that Google is making us stupid. As a counterpoint, NPR's Alva Noë argues that Google is just another tool that allows us to extend our brains, similar to dog-earing a page in a book.

In fact, Noë believes that the way we use Google is a very natural expression of our evolution:

We have evolved not to be representers-of-the-world, but to lock-in and keep track of where we find ourselves. We use landmarks and street signs to find our way around; arithmetical notation makes it possible for us to calculate with big numbers; we wear wrist watches so that we can know the time without needing to know the time; and we build libraries so that we have access to what we need to know, when we need to know it.

The so-called Google effect is merely the latest expression of a cognitive strategy that is almost as certainly as ancient as our species.

The argument, as Noë presents it, is that yes, technology is changing our lives. It just isn't changing the way that our minds work. It's an interesting perspective, and one that might ease your anxiety if you're concerned that Google's made you dumb (Noë suggests finding something else to worry about). Hit the link below for the full post, and agree or not, share your thoughts in the comments.

Google Is Not Making You Stupid [NPR]


Comments

    Can't wait for the day I can put a chip in my head that gives me a massive amount of extra Ram, and allows me to access 'Google' in my head..! #]

    If you think Google or Wiki makes you stupid, please don't have a child. Take your stupidity to your own grave!

    I found Deus Ex: HR provided an interesting discussion of the same idea (where google can be seen as a human augmentation, just as a watch or an iPhone can be seen as one).

    Stupid is a relative term ... those that embrace "Google" are likely to regard those that don't as stupid and vice versa.

    The fact is, the way we think, communicate and interact changes; always has; always will.

Join the discussion!

Trending Stories Right Now