How BlackBerry Overcame My Resistance To Touch Screens

One of my main reasons for using a BlackBerry has always been that I do a lot of writing and text manipulation on my phone while travelling, and for those purposes a well-designed built-in keyboard is essential. But I've had to face facts: in recent months, I've been using its touch-screen interface a lot more than I realised.

I've been rocking the BlackBerry Torch as my main smart phone pretty much ever since it was launched last October. That in itself marks a significant change in my attitude towards earlier touch-screen BlackBerry devices. I described the original as having "the worst text input system I’ve ever seen on a portable device" and the Storm 2 as a "right royal pain" to type on; I didn't stick with using either device any longer than it took to finish reviewing them.

The immediate and obvious difference with the Torch is that it has a proper slide-out keyboard, rather than a poorly-realised touch-screen interface. It also still has the joystick-like pointer control, which means that for existing BlackBerry users, you can pick it up and start using it straight away. And that was exactly what I did: I remember being at the media launch and navigating rapidly through apps in the usual way, while everyone around me was busy playing with the screen. I definitely liked the extra screen real estate, the ability to browse more complex sites and the overall BlackBerry 6 OS experience, but for me touch was just a minor useful addition, and one I didn't see myself using too much.

That remains true when it comes to writing, handling email, browsing and using WordPress, which are my key BlackBerry tasks. But it was only when I started testing out the recently-released BlackBerry Bold 9780 -- which offers the BlackBerry 6 OS experience but in a non-touch environment with a traditional BlackBerry form factor -- that I realised that I do actually use the touch interface fairly often.

I've become used to flicking across from the main screen to access the connection manager on the phone's frequently-used apps page. On the Bold, which only offers a single row of app icons by default, this is a rather more time-consuming task. I also now oscillate between using the control stick to launch new apps or simply touching them, although when switching between open apps I still find the non-touch version faster. And when I went to photograph the two devices and realised that the Torch was in fact filthy with fingerprints by comparison, I had to admit that my stance had obviously softened.

While I'm happy sticking to the Torch, the Bold 9780 still has appeal: Vodafone and 3 sell it on cheaper monthly caps than the Torch is available for, and it weighs noticeably less than the Torch. But for me, it's served as a reminder that while I don't want to touchscreen-type, I'm less opposed to touch interfaces than I used to be.

Lifehacker Australia editor Angus Kidman clearly needs to start travelling with a packet of screen wipes. His Road Worrier column, looking at technology and organising tips for travellers, appears each week on Lifehacker.


Comments

    Screen protectors / wipes - All rubbish

    A bit of grease on the screen makes it good for navigating - only time I like to clean mine is for watching videos

    If needed - a buff on the shirt usualy cleans the screen satisfactorily - for dirtier screens - a moist tissue again followed by a dry buff

    2 years - these methods and my screen still looks pristine

      I pretty much agree with this.

      I am inclined to use a screen protector as a lot of them have a nicer finish and thus your finger moves more smoothly on them when they are dirty.

      Shirt buffing is the way to clean it too :)

    The Palm Pre did exactly the same thing for me. At first I was like 'eww touchscreens!' and I got the Pre to have hardware keyboard with touchscreen.

    I've since gone fully touchscreen (nexus one).

    Also, yeah, protectors etc are a load of crap. If you're gonna do that, why not go ahead and put plastic over your lounge or a 'car bra' over your headlights and grill.

    IMO Swype has gone a long way toward making the touchscreen a viable method for entering lots of text. I can't Swype quite as fast as I can type on a full sized keyboard, but I reckon I could easily exceed the speed I could achieve on one of those dinky little keyboards like the Blackberry has.

      I like Swype, but I can go way faster with a BB keyboard.

        I love the blackberry keyboards, but I haven't been able to get up to quite the same speed on the 9700 and 9800 as I did on the bold 9000 - my fingers are just slightly too fat and unwieldy for them.

        However, RIM are apparently releasing a touchscreen phone with the same physical proportions as the 9000 later this year, so my dreams could be answered. I'll certainly be grabbing a demo unit to see how it stacks up against the torch 2.

    MMS on Torch: Does not resize images automatically, must set image size to small, then take photo to send. seems a lil silly, but there you go. Just saying, as I have had many calls from Torch users wondering why MMS send fails ;-)

Join the discussion!