Write Caching For USB Devices In Windows? Just Don't Bother

Being a stickler for performance, the first things I do with a fresh Windows install is fix the swap file size, turn off all the fancy animations and shut off unneeded services. I also make sure to switch on write-caching for all my USB drives as I use them — the option is better known by its user-friendly name "Better performance". Turns out the benefits might only be as high as five percent. At worst, it can actually hurt transfer speeds.

Benchmark images: 7Tutorials

The folks over at 7Tutorials decided to run a few benchmarks on this feature to find out if the annoyance of having to select "Safely remove device" every time you yank out a USB drive is worth the trouble. The tests were carried out with CrystalDiskMark and three drives: a Corsair Voyager GT 16GB, a LaCie 1TB external hard drive and a 2GB "no-name" thumb drive.

For the Corsair and no-name flash drives, read performance dropped less than five per cent and about one per cent, respectively. Surprisingly, both experienced a boost in read performance, but it was never larger than one per cent.

How about the hard drive? Maybe its use of traditional — and slower — magnetic media might see some bigger differences. Well, have a look for yourself.

With write-caching enabled.

With write-caching disabled.

Don't be afraid to wear your unimpressed face.

The moral of the story? If you're not completely insane about the performance of your external USB drives, save yourself some hassle and just keep them on the "Quick removal" setting.

Want to Stop Using the Safely Remove Hardware Notification Icon? [7Tutorials, via AddictiveTips]


Comments

    All of my flashdrives go from about 8mbps with caching enabled, and around 25mbps with it off. Same with my externals!

    I've found that write caching helps very significantly when dealing with large numbers of small files, and large amounts of file manipulation.

    Having said that, I'm not surprised by the conclusion of the article; I would think that write caching off would be the most appropriate setting for most people and applications.

    One other thing that Safely Remove Hardware does is check for open file handles on the device. Handy if you left a Microsoft Word document on the USB drive open, for example. :)

Join the discussion!

Trending Stories Right Now